Political aspects make caste based reservation inefficient compared to income based reservation both the reservation systems have their advantages and disadvantages for a country like india where scrapping reservation doesn’t seem like a viable option as long as politicians are afraid of losing their power. Ncdhr's beena pallical explains why reservations were instituted in india, and why they can't be on an economic basis right now. If you want caste based reservation why you become an atheist better to be a theist and work in a caste based organisation” many including me immediately opposed his views the concise of opposing views was this caste is not like a god belief one cannot get out of your caste by simply not believing in god. Caste-based reservations will do nothing but damage the indian economy eventually how well, for example let's say a person has been provided employment on caste quota basis (and not on the basis of knowledge).
Highlights up medical education department refuted reports of yogi government abolishing reservations in private medical colleges it said caste-based reservation was never a part of the . The haryana insaf society organised a discussion on caste-based reservation-a menace to the society on sunday. Ththe nair service society (nss) has moved the supreme court of india contending that caste-based reservation will damage the social equilibrium of kerala.
If combined with about 9 per cent of the scheduled tribe (st) and 20 per cent of the scheduled caste (sc) population, the total proportion eligible for reservation comprises 73 per cent of the indian population if new claimants to the obc category are added to this group, easily 80 per cent of indians would be eligible for reservation of some kind. In actual sense the caste based reservation stands for parity, representation, human rights and is a defence mechanism against any and every case of caste based discrimination and exclusion reservation policy is a means to have equal say in the policy making and governance as well. Reservations based upon the economic strata and the change of the mindset is the key to the betterment and to settle the future of the nation time has come to remove the caste based reservations in india.
Q caste is a phenomenon of the past that is slowly fading away caste based reservation will only accentuate the underlying ills of the caste system a one need to realize that caste is not fading away. After india achieved independence, the policy of caste-based reservation of jobs was formalised with lists of scheduled castes and scheduled tribes. This article talks in detail whether the caste based reservation is good or bad along with the history associated with it and the alternatives available. ‘caste is a thing of the past, there is no discrimination based on caste now,’ ‘reservations have already benefitted the lower caste people and it is the upper caste now which is at the receiving end of discrimination’ are among the common complaints against caste-based reservations. Education is to be for deserved rather than reserved are these caste based reservations really a boon to the society or are they discriminating under the drape of equality .
Caste based reservation is an important catalyst to social reform also, to make sure the targeted citizens enjoy the benefits, creamy layer (family earnings up to 6lpa) of obc category has been excluded from reservation. India against reservation is campaign against the cast basis reservation in education and governmental services we just want to remove reservation from higher education and governmental jobs, to help all the caste to get a chance for which they deserve. Local self-governments have caste, tribe and gender based reservation system in place reservations in employment [ edit ] a fixed percentage of india's government and public sector jobs are made exclusive for categories of people largely based on their caste or tribe. Caste-based reservations: ambedkar backed rethink on quotas we’ve done nothing, says sumitra mahajan “ambedkar himself sought a 10-year review, we haven’t achieved the society of his dreams,” says speaker. By mary honey though we all live in a democratic country where everyone enjoys freedom and equality (only written in constitution), the caste reservation sometimes makes a hindrance for everyone from enjoying equality due to the attractive allowances offered by the government there are instances.
Time has come to remove the caste based reservations in india reservations based upon the economic strata and the change of the mindset is the key to the betterment and to settle the future of the nation. The caste-based reservation system gives great opportunities to backward classes in government sector but it leave people of general caste with very little opportunities if reservation system ends, government jobs will become approachable for each class of the society. Demerits of caste based reservation system question - sc recently quashed a central government notification granting obc/other backward classes status to jat community in 9 states discuss the demerits of caste based reservation system efforts need to be made to dilute the caste based reservation system.
Is meritocracy better than reservation (affirmative action or positive discrimination) for marginalized groups in nepal. The reservation policy was intended to redress caste-based inequalities it was thought to be reviewd every twn years and removed when social justice for all was achieved however, the reservation system has been expanded to include the obcs. If caste is introduced, the identity of those not performing will unnecessarily come up, which is self-defeating caste-based reservation will hit indian cricket for a six, and leave talent . Reservation provides social inclusion if it caste based: caste based reservation aims to enable education and employment representation for social groups that have even been excluded from the same for many years.
Caste based reservation promotion quota without data to be excessive, supreme court told govt has asked sc to revisit an earlier ruling that made it mandatory for the state to justify reservations in promotions. Rishav sircar needs your help with “prime minister narendra modi: remove the caste based reservation system” join rishav and 321,473 supporters today join rishav and 321,473 supporters today sign this petition. With regards to the question as to how long should caste based reservation continue there can only be one answer until and unless the attributes of the caste system vanishes how could people .